If I told everyone I’m friends with on Facebook that I had filmed a sex-tape and that the damn thing was stolen and perhaps about to appear online, reactions would probably be limited to disgusted pity or a resigned lack of surprise (obviously I'm joking, it would really fucking suck). If an established band from L.A tells everyone that the private sex-tape they made as a couple has been stolen and possibly about to be posted online, a different reaction altogether comes about.
ICYMI, the romantic duo/band Yacht recently found themselves in this exact predicament and wrote a big upsetting letter about it on Facebook.
“Dear everyone,
We are writing today because we want you to be the first to know some news.
This has been a hard time for us as a band. It’s hard for bands generally these days. We make music in a time where album sales are at an all time low. Tours are a formidable expense with no guarantees that we’ll make the money back. Not even t-shirts sell the way that they used to. Music isn’t art anymore, it’s just content. We don’t need to write yet another op-ed column to describe the intricacies of why mid-level bands like us are in trouble.
That being said…
Today, without our previous knowledge nor consent, a personal video was released.
For more than 10 years, Claire and I have been the frontman and frontwoman of a band that has been core to the meaning of our mutual existence. YACHT is the result of love, tremendous work and unending, unflinching collaboration. We have always operated under the principle of doing our best to maintain dignity and a commitment to openness and truth, both on stage and off.
But today, due to a series of technological missteps and one morally abject person, a video that we made privately has been released to the public. We have commenced legal proceedings against the aforementioned person, but now that it could potentially circulate, we feel like it’s important for you to know what happened and why.
Claire and I — who have been romantic and artistic partners since 2006 — made a “sex tape.” It was intended for us only. We don’t feel the need to justify the reason we made it. Anyone reading this who has been in a long term partnership understands that preserving the relationship is an ever-changing and challenging thing. It’s especially difficult when the lines between career and romance are as merged as ours are. The financial pressures that we’ve been under, which de facto extend into our extracurricular lives, created a circumstance in which we felt like we needed a bit of an escape from the day-to-day. So we turned on a camera, became naked, and had sex. We assumed that we were the only people who would be privy to that video. I guess we were naive. Now you have the option to be privy to that video. For us, that’s a shame. We feel like art is an act of generosity. The art we make for the public is for that expressed purpose. And now we’re in an awkward situation where the art that we made for us and us alone is being viewed by anyone who has the inclination to hit play — a true and humiliating blurring of the public and private.
Our tastes in the bedroom might seem uncommon to some, and possibly off-putting. But considering the variables that go into any sexual experience, wouldn’t anything seem uncommon, and possibly off-putting? This is our private life. And no one should have governance over what people do consensually in their private lives.
Just because we are public figures does not mean we asked for this. Like anyone, we still deserve to have a choice about what we share with the world. Today we no longer have that choice. But our hope is that you fundamentally understand that choice and you choose not to view a private act that was inadvertently made public. We hope you understand that this is not a delicious scandal. This is an exploitation.
We love you all and hope that you will make the right decision. And if you don’t, we hope that you will continue to enjoy our music regardless of what you’ve seen today.
With love and respect,
Jona and Claire”
Fans were bereft of their faith in humanity, and offered consoling cyber-hugs and good vibrational support. You know, genuine human sympathy. Yacht then set up a web-page where their sex-crazed, foaming-at-the-mouth fans could go to buy the tape direct from the band - if they absolutely had to see it.
As It turns out, Yacht set the whole operation up themselves as a way to promote their new video (music, not porn – but it is called “I Wanna Fuck You Til I’m Dead”).
The incident was documented by a Jezebel writer called Anna Merlan, who initially wrote an article about Yacht selling their own sex-tape for $5 under the suspicion that all wasn’t genuine. Merlan noted that upon trying to download the tape, an error message appeared, and it seemed like the only people able to access it were Yacht's famous friends. The next day one of her co-workers forwarded her an email sent from Yacht dated April 6 which very clearly outlined their plans to create a faux-victimization promo stunt in the form of a faked sex-tape leak. Merlan’s updated article tears Yacht a new (you can read it here).
The email from Yacht’s frontwoman Claire L. Evans reads:
“For the upcoming music video for our song, “I Wanna Fuck You Til I’m Dead,” we’re faking a sex tape leak.
In the days leading up to the video’s release, we’re going to pretend we were hacked, share and delete confessional social media posts on the subject of our privacy, then try to “get out in front of it” and sell the sex tape, fake a server crash, etc.”
People have been hitting out at Yacht to say that their actions have been irresponsible and a mockery of real victims of private images being published online without their consent. As noted by many, genuine victims have gone as far as to commit suicide to escape the personal videos and pictures of themselves that have appeared online.
A statement from Yacht explaining why they did this is now what takes up the web-space at the URL they posted on Facebook for the tape’s download (don’t worry, it's SFW.) They say that the stunt was to play with elements of “science fiction, the attention economy, clickbait journalism, and celebrity sex tapes all at once.” They also stress how disturbing they find it that journalists have made the leaping connection between revenge-porn and its victims, and Yacht’s actions. This is apparently about “agency and proactive empowerment.” Revenge porn, in the words of Yacht, is “unfunny, disgusting, morally repugnant, and completely unrelated.”
Unfortunately, there’s a gaping hole in Yacht’s justification. One of the major plot-points in their first big Facebook post about the whole thing is the fact that the tape was stolen without their consent. They pretended to be victims of something different, but no less reprehensible than “revenge porn” and even created a fictional, “morally abject” character on which to pin the blame – it makes no difference that this was probably part of their celebrity sex-tape parody schtick. Yacht say that the stunt was "to explore the intersection of privacy, media, and celebrity," and that it wasn't to make money or sell records. Perhaps if Yacht had penned a Facebook letter to their fans that was a little heavier on humour and a little lighter on staight up lying about their own exploitation then that would be easier to believe. Selling a few more records was just a side-bonus, right Yacht?
It would be heinous to say the 4chan users who violated Jennifer Lawrence, Kaley Cuoco, and Kate Upton amongst others, by stealing over 200 private photos and plastering them on the internet in 2014 didn’t commit a serious crime against privacy. It would also be plain dumb to think that this kind of thing doesn’t happen to non-celebrities, too. In fact it’s probably worse if you aren’t a celebrity.
Yacht are either so committed to their art that they can’t see how stupidly offensive their actions have been, or they’ve spun a PR web so dense that they feel that turning back now would be a sign of weakness. Either way, real people have been victims of cyber-theft involving personal and graphic images, and all the bullshit Yacht posted about how the situation "is a violation" probably doesn't even scratch the surface of how terrible and confusing it feels when it happens to you in real life.
The leap between “revenge porn” and what Yacht claimed to be victims of simply isn’t a very big one. Maybe Yacht genuinely feel like they were creating an exhibition of how to deal with such a situation in a direct and candid way, but acting with confidence in the face of such a fucked-up and exposing predicament is a lot more difficult when said predicament isn't fucking fictional.
image: boatinternational.com